A black and white logo for the pizzeria on a white background.

Bay Shore

PURCHASE E-GIFT CARD

Gift cards can be used at any of our locations

11 Maple Ave., Bay Shore, NY 11706

(631) 686-3555


Hours

Mon - Thu
-
Fri - Sat
-
Sunday
-
Two plates of food are on a wooden table in a restaurant.

Download Our Menus

Join us for

Happy Hour

Monday - Thursday  |  3:00-6:00pm

Discounted Drinks & Appetizers

$13 Personal Pies

View Menu

Lunch & Dinner Menu

A bowl of meatballs and bread on a wooden table.

Menu

APPETIZERS

Whipped Ricotta Toast

Honey with Lemon Zest or Hot Honey and Chili Flakes

Arancini

arborio rice | chopped meat | pecorino | vodka sauce

Calamari

Traditional • Rhode Island • Arrabiata • Thai Chili • Buffalo

Baked Clams

seasoned breadcrumbs | garlic | lemon | summer sauce

Summer Shrimp

white wine | lemon | butter | garlic sauce | rustic bread

Homemade Meatballs

tomato sauce | ricotta | parmesan | basil | rustic bread

Menu

Tuscan Cuddles

prosciutto di parma | stracciatella cheese | arugula | fried dough

Burrata Rustica

burrata cheese | cherry tomatoes | arugula | olive oil | rustic bread 


add Prosciutto di Parma +5

Vodka Fritters

spaghetti | vodka sauce | guanciale | bread crumbs

Wings

Buffalo • Dry Rub • Thai Chili • BBQ

Hand Cut Fries

Truffle Parmesan or Sea Salt

Chicken Roll

breaded chicken | mozzarella | tomato sauce | parmesan & garlic seasoning

Mozzarella Sticks
Fried Ravioli
CALZONES

Traditional or Crumbled Sausage & Pepperoni

A salad with chicken , apples , and lettuce on a white plate.

Menu

SALADS

House

mixed field greens | cherry tomatoes | red onion | cucumbers | freshly made croutons | mozzarella

Caesar

romaine | shaved parmesan cheese | parmesan crisps | freshly made croutons | homemade caesar dressing

The Salad

mixed field greens | honey crisp apple sticks | cherry tomatoes | croutons | candied pecans | parmesan crisps | cheddar cheese 

Primiano Chop

soppressata | prosciutto | fresh mozzarella | onions | sliced cherry peppers | romaine | tomato | red wine vinaigrette

DRESSINGS

House Vinaigrette  • Homemade Caesar • Ranch • Blue Cheese • Balsamic • Red Wine Vinaigrette

A chicken parmesan sandwich is cut in half on a white plate.

Menu

HEROS

Parmigiana

Chicken • Meatball • Shrimp • Eggplant • Sausage

tomato or vodka sauce | mozzarella | semolina bread

The Hero

Chicken • Meatball • Shrimp • Eggplant • Sausage

burrata cheese | tomato sauce | fresh basil | olive oil | parmesan | semolina bread

Primiano Chop Hero

soppressata | prosciutto | fresh mozzarella | onions | tomato | sliced cherry peppers | romaine | red wine vinaigrette | semolina bread

FOCACCIA SANDWICHES

Prosciutto

prosciutto di parma | fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil

Pesto Chicken

grilled chicken | fresh mozzarella | roasted red peppers | house made pesto

Caprese

fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil

WRAPS

Grilled Chicken Caesar

romaine | grilled chicken | parmesan | homemade caesar dressing

The Pizzeria Chicken

arugula | roasted peppers | breaded chicken | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze

Menu

PASTA

Penne Alla Vodka

housemade vodka sauce | penne pasta

The Mezzi Rig

mezzi rigatoni | mozzarella | spicy vodka sauce

Gnocchi

Tomato Sauce or Creamy Pesto 

add  Breaded Chickent Cutlet +4

Beggar's Purse

cheese filled pasta puches | crumbled spicy sausage | vodka sauce

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage

orecchiete | broccoli rabe | crumbled sausage | garlic & oil

Endless Summer Shrimp

white wine, lemon, butter, garlic sauce | shrimp | spaghetti

Cacio e Pepe

traditional roman style

GLUTEN-FREE PASTA AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST

PIZZA

A pizza with a slice being taken out of it

Menu

ROUND PIES

Regular

traditional new york style | 18"

Bay Shore PIe

fresh mozzarella | pizza sauce | parmesan | olive oil crust

Vodka Margherita

fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | parmesan | olive oil crust

Bar Pie

pizza sauce | light mozzarella | burrata | hot honey | basil | olive oil crust

Tri-Fecta

fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | pizza sauce | pesto | olive oil crust

Uncle Benny

fresh mozzarella | cup & char pepperoni | pizza sauce | crumbled sausage | hot honey | basil | olive oil crust

Bruschetta

balsamic-infused crust | fresh bruschetta | burrata cheese | basil | balsamic glaze

Buffalo Chicken

marinated chicken | mozzarella | buffalo sauce

Chicken Bacon Ranch

breaded chicken | crispy bacon | mozzarella | cheddar | ranch

A pizza is sitting on a wire rack on a wooden table.

Menu

SQUARE PIES

Grandma

marinara | mozzarella | grandma style crust

Upside Down

mozzarella | marinara | olive oil | sicilian crust

The Honey Pep

cup & char pepperoni | hot honey | basil | sicilian crust

Crumbling Vodka

fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | spicy crumbled sausage | grandma style crust

Sicilian

pizza sauce | mozzarella | thick sicilian crust

Meatball Burrata

homemade meatballs | tomato sauce | burrata | basil | parmesan cheese | grandma style crust

White

ricotta | marscapone | mozzarella | white truffle oil | grandma style crust

Thai Chili Chicken

marinated chicken | mozzarella | thai chili sauce | grandma style crust

Menu

PERSONAL PIES

Bay Shore Pie
Vodka Margherita
Bar Pie
Tri-Fecta
Uncle Benny
Stracciatella
Prosciutto Arugula
Eggplant Rollatini
Meatball Burrata
Bruschetta
White
Crumbling Vodka
Thai Chili Chicken
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Gluten-Free
chicken milanese on white plate

Menu

DINNERS

includes choice of pasta or side salad

Parmigiana

Chicken • Meatball • Eggplant • Shrimp

with tomato or vodka sauce

The Pizzeria Chicken

breaded chicken cutlet topped with arugula | cherry tomato | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze

Chicken Francese

whtie wine lemon butter sauce

Chicken Stracciatella

breaded chicken cutlet | vodka sauce | creamy stracciatella cheese

Endless Summer Chicken

breaded chicken cutlet | fresh mozzarella | white wine lemon sauce

Rustic Shrimp

breaded shrimp | rustic wine sauce | fresh mozzarella

ON THE LIGHTER SIDE

Grilled Pizzeria Chicken

seasoned grilled chicken topped with arugula | cherry tomato | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze

Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe

sautéed broccoli rabe | garlic | seasoned grilled chicken

Cocktails

Cocktails

SIGNATURE

McCartney's Marg

tequila | blood orange | triple sec | lime

Cucumber Mint Martini

vodka or gin | lemon | muddled cucumber | mint

Little Sicilian

limoncello | prosecco | lemon | mint

Paper Plane

bourbon | amaro | aperol | lemon | orange twist

Max’s Old Fashioned

bourbon | muddled orange & cherry | angostura bitters

The Main Street

gin | st. germaine | pineapple | lime | bubbles

Bees Knees

gin | lemon | honey

Espresso Martini

la colombe espresso | vanilla vodka | borghetti coffee liqueur

SPIRIT-FREE

Cucumber & Spice

muddled cucumber & jalapeño | lemon | lime | club soda

Blood Orange Spritz

blood orange juice | lemon | honey | fever tree sicilian lemonade

Specials

Cocktails

APPETIZER

Short Rib Arancini

slow-braised short rib | risotto | pan sauce

Cauliflower Fritto

crispy breaded cauliflower

CHOOSE   Buffalo • Parmesan • Classic • Buffalo 

SOUP & SALAD

The Chicken Soup

our take on classic chicken noodle soup

Homemade Tomato Soup

splash of cream | served with rustic grilled cheese

Harvest Salad

kale | arugula | goat cheese | honey crisp apples | sliced almonds | dried cranberries

PERSONAL PIE

The Aunt Danielle Pie

vodka sauce | pepperoni | stracciatella cheese | fresh basil | hot honey

PASTA

Short Rib Pappardelle

slow-braised short rib | pan sauce | grated parm

Bolognese

mezzi rig | ground beef | crumbled sausage | marinara sauce | dollop of fresh ricotta cheese

Lobster Ravioli

sautéed cherry tomatoes | lemon | basil

ENTRÉE

Veggie Stack

grilled zucchini | battered eggplant | mozzarella | vodka | marinara sauce

DESSERT

Tartufo

Vanilla & Chocolate or Pistachio

NY Style Cheesecake

Rainbow Cookies
Flourless Chocolate Truffle Cake

COCKTAILS

Peartini

vodka | elderflower | triple sec | pear | lime

Maple Whiskey Sour

bourbon | lemon | maple | angostura

Pama Cosmo

vodka | pama | lemon | pomegranate

Golden Hour

light & spiced rum | blood orange | lemon | pear

Seasonal Sangria

ask server for details

The Cooper

reposado tequila | amaro | honey | lemon | fire tincture

SPIRIT-FREE

Pom Paloma

pomegranate | lemon | simple | sparkling grapefruit


add Vodka • Rum • Tequila • Gin +6

Share by: