A black and white logo for the pizzeria on a white background.

Islip

PURCHASE E-GIFT CARD

Gift cards can be used at any of our locations

591 Main St, Islip, NY 11751

(631) 581-9500


Hours

Mon - Thu
-
Friday
-
Sat - Sun
-
A variety of pizzas are displayed in a glass case.

Lunch & Dinner Menu

A bowl of meatballs and bread on a wooden table.

Menu

SMALL BITES

Garlic Knots

.70

Buffalo Knots

.70

Rice Ball

1.95

Pepperoni or Broccoli Pinwheel

4.50

Garlic Bread

with mozzarella on focaccia  6.95

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

10.95

Menu

Calzone

baked or fried. 10.95

Chicken Roll

10.95

Mozzarella Sticks

10.95

Fried Ravioli

10.95

Meatballs

11.95

Wings

Buffalo • BBQ • Thai Chili • Dry Rub. 15.95

A salad with chicken , apples , and lettuce on a white plate.

Menu

SALADS

The Salad

mixed field greens | honey crisp apple sticks | cherry tomatoes | croutons | candied pecans | parmesan crisps | cheddar cheese  15.95

House

mixed field greens | cherry tomatoes | red onion | cucumbers | freshly made croutons | mozzarella. 13.95

Caesar

romaine | shaved parmesan cheese | parmesan crisps | freshly made croutons | homemade caesar dressing  14.95

DRESSINGS

House Vinaigrette  • Homemade Caesar • Ranch • Blue Cheese • Balsamic

A chicken parmesan sandwich is cut in half on a white plate.

Menu

HEROS

Parmigiana

Chicken • Meatball • Shrimp • Eggplant • Sausage

tomato or vodka sauce | mozzarella | semolina bread. 13.95

The Hero

Chicken • Meatball • Shrimp • Eggplant • Sausage

burrata cheese | tomato sauce | fresh basil | olive oil | parmesan | semolina bread 15.95

FOCACCIA SANDWICHES

Prosciutto

prosciutto di parma | fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil

Pesto Chicken

grilled chicken | fresh mozzarella | roasted red peppers | house made pesto  13.95

Caprese

fresh mozzarella | tomato | basil | olive oil  11.95

Menu

PASTA

Penne Alla Vodka

housemade vodka sauce | penne pasta  19.95

The Mezzi Rig

mezzi rigatoni | mozzarella | spicy vodka sauce  19.95

Beggar's Purse

cheese filled pasta puches | crumbled spicy sausage | vodka sauce  19.95

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage

orecchiete | broccoli rabe | crumbled sausage | garlic & oil  19.95

Pasta with Meatballs

19.95

Baked Ziti

17.95

PASTA OPTIONS

Mezzi Rigatoni • Penne • Spaghetti • Gluten-Free 

PIZZA

A pizza with a slice being taken out of it

Menu

ROUND PIES

Regular

traditional new york style   20.95

Islip Pie

(our margarita) fresh mozzarella | pizza sauce | parmesan | olive oil crust  28.95

Vodka Margherita

fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | parmesan | olive oil crust  28.95

Bar Pie

pizza sauce | light mozzarella | burrata | hot honey | basil | olive oil crust  28.95

Tri-Fecta

fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | pizza sauce | pesto | olive oil crust  29.95

Uncle Benny

fresh mozzarella | cup & char pepperoni | pizza sauce | crumbled sausage | hot honey | basil | olive oil crust

Bruschetta

balsamic-infused crust | fresh bruschetta | burrata cheese | basil | balsamic glaze  32.95

Buffalo Chicken

marinated chicken | mozzarella | buffalo sauce  31.95

Chicken Bacon Ranch

breaded chicken | crispy bacon | mozzarella | cheddar | ranch  31.95

A pizza is sitting on a wire rack on a wooden table.

Menu

SQUARE PIES

Grandma

marinara | mozzarella | grandma style crust 23.95

Upside Down

mozzarella | marinara | olive oil | sicilian crust  27.95

The Honey Pep

cup & char pepperoni | hot honey | basil | sicilian crust  29.95

Crumbling Vodka

fresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | spicy crumbled sausage | grandma style crust  29.95

Sicilian

pizza sauce | mozzarella | thick sicilian crust  23.95

Meatball Burrata

homemade meatballs | tomato sauce | burrata | basil | parmesan cheese | grandma style crust  29.95

White

ricotta | marscapone | mozzarella | white truffle oil | grandma style crust  28.95

Thai Chili Chicken

marinated chicken | mozzarella | thai chili sauce | grandma style crust  29.95

Gluten-Free Personal Pie

Gluten-Free & Dairy Free Crust  15.95

chicken milanese on white plate

Menu

DINNERS

includes choice of pasta or side salad

Parmigiana

Chicken • Meatball • Eggplant • Shrimp

with tomato or vodka sauce  23.95

The Pizzeria Chicken

breaded chicken cutlet topped with arugula | cherry tomato | fresh mozzarella | balsamic glaze 23.95

Chicken Francese

whtie wine lemon butter sauce  23.95

DESSERT

Zeppole

.90

Mini Cannoli

2.50

Share by: